—"If any player shall intentionally trip put on hold an opposing player, or deliberately handle the ball within twelve yards from his own goal-line, the referee shall, on appeal, award the opposing side a penalty kick, to be taken from any point twelve yards from the goal-line, under the following conditions:-All players, with the exception of the player taking the penalty kick and the opposing goal-keeper (who shall not advance more than six yards from the goal-line) shall stand at least six yards behind the ball. The ball shall be in play when the kick is taken, and a goal may be scored from the penalty kick." - 2 June 1891, Glasgow
 
"but the ball shall not be again played by the kicker until it has been played by another player. If necessary, time of play shall be extended to admit of the penalty kick being taken." - 13 June 1892, Llandudno

1898-99
18 February 1899, 13-2 vs. Ireland, Roker Park Ground, Sunderland.
Joe McAllen, the Irish Captain, scored the first-ever successfully converted penalty kick against the debuting Jack Hillman, possibly after 65 minutes. Jimmy Crabtree had committed the foul that led to the penalty kick.

—"A suitable mark shall be made opposite each goal-post, 18 yards from the goal-line, to assist the Referee in enforcing the regulations as regards the penalty kick under Law 14.". - 17 June 1901, Giant's Causeway

—"In the event of any intentional infringement of Law 10 by the defending side within the penalty area, the Referee shall award the opponents a penalty kick which shall be taken from the penalty kick mark under the following conditions ;—All players, with the exception of the player taking the penalty kick and the opponents' goal-keeper shall be outside the penalty area. The opponents' goal-keeper shall be within the goal area. The ball must be kicked forward. The ball shall be in play when the kick is taken, and a goal may be scored from a penalty kick ; but the ball shall not be again played by the kicker until it has been played by another player. If necessary, time of play shall be extended to admit of the penalty kick being taken. A free kick shall also be awarded to the opposite side if the ball is not kicked forward, or is played a second time by the player who takes the penalty kick, until it has been played by another player." - 16 June 1902, Scarborough

1908-09
1 June 1909, 8-1 vs. Austria, Hohe Warte Stadion, Wien
Leopold Neubauer, or Ludwig Hussak, scored Austria's only goal, a penalty kick, against Sam Hardy, timing not known.

1919-20
15 March 1920, 1-2 vs. Wales, Arsenal Stadium, Highbury
Stanley Davies equalised with his 14th minute penalty kick against Sam Hardy, after captain Jesse Pennington had handled in the area.

1923-24
1 November 1923, 2-2 vs. Belgium, Bosuil Stadion, Antwerpen
Achille Schelstraete scored his 75th (tbc) minute penalty kick against the debuting Ted Hufton.

1926-27
12 February 1927, 3-3 vs. Wales, Racecourse Ground, Wrexham
Len Davies scored his 36th minute penalty kick against the debuting Jack Brown. George Green was adjudged to have tackled Rees Williams unfairly.

1927-28
19 May 1928, 3-1 vs. Belgium, Olympisch Stadion, Antwerp
Jacques Moeschal opening goal after 25 minutes was awarded after Vince Matthews handled the ball, but it is unsure whether the kick was taken from inside or outside the penalty area.

1935-36
4 April 1936, 1-1 vs. Scotland, Empire Stadium, London
20 year-old Tommy Walker scored a 77th minute penalty kick.  After a free-kick, debutant John Crum was brought down on the six-yard box. Keeping his nerve as the wind blew the ball of the spot, Walker scored against Ted Sagar.

1937-38
21 May 1938, 1-2 vs. Switzerland, Hardturm Stadion, Zürich
André Abegglen scored a penalty kick against Vic Woodley, timing not known.

1947-48
19 November 1947, 4-2 vs. Sweden, Arsenal Stadium, Highbury
Gunnar Gren scored a 60th minute penalty kick against Frank Swift.

1949-50
21 September 1949, 0-2 vs. Ireland, Goodison Park, Liverpool
Con Martin scored a 33rd minute powerful penalty kick that despite a Bert Williams save, spun over the line, after Bert Mozley had brough down Peter Desmond.

1951-52
28 November 1951, 2-2 vs. Austria, Empire Stadium, Wembley
Ernst Stojaspal scored a 88th minute penalty kick against Gil Merrick, after Bill Eckersley prevented a certain goal using his hand.
25 May 1952, 2-3 vs. Austria, Praterstadion, Wien
Adolf Huber scored a 28th minute penalty kick towards Gil Merrick's right, after Robert Dienst was chasing a long ball and collapsed when Jack Froggatt attempted to tackle him. Dienst had kicked the ball too far in front of him.

1952-53
8 June 1953, 6-3 vs. USA, Yankee Stadium, New York
George Athineos scored a 66th minute penalty kick against Ted Ditchburn, after Harry Johnston had handled the ball in the area.

1953-54
21 October 1953, 4-4 vs, Rest of the World, Empire Stadium, Wembley
Ladislav Kubala scored a slow, precise sixth minute penalty kick to Gil Merrick's right after a Bernard Vukas was clipped from behind sprinting into the area by Bill Eckersley.

1954-55
15 May 1955, 0-1 vs. France, Stade Olympique Yves-du-Manoir, Paris
Raymond Kopa scored the only goal of the match in a 37th minute penalty kick against Bert Williams.

1957-58
6 November 1957, 2-3 vs. Northern Ireland, Empire Stadium, Wembley
Jimmy Mcllroy scored his 32nd minute penalty kick against Eddie Hopkinson, awarded against a Billy Wright foul. His kick hit the post and went in off Hopkinson's head.

1961-62
14 April 1962, 0-2 vs. Scotland, Hampden Park, Glasgow
Eric Caldow scored an 88th minute penalty kick against Ron Springett.

1962-63
6 April 1963, 1-2 vs. Scotland, Empire Stadium, Wembley
Jim Baxter scored his penalty kick in the 32nd minute against the debuting Gordon Banks.

1966 World Cup Finals
26 July 1966, 2-1 vs. Portugal, Empire Stadium, Wembley
Eusébio scored his penalty kick in the 82nd minute against Gordon Banks.

1968-69
15 January 1969, 1-1 vs. Romania, Empire Stadium, Wembley
Florea Dumitrache scored his penalty kick in the 74th minute against Gordon Banks.

1971-72
29 April 1972, 1-3 vs. West Germany, Empire Stadium, Wembley
Günter Netzer scored his penalty kick in the 85th minute against Gordon Banks.

1972-73
12 May 1973, 2-1 vs. Northern Ireland, Goodison Park, Liverpool
Dave Clements scored a 22nd minute penalty kick low to the right of Peter Shilton, awarded after Peter Storey elbowed Sammy Morgan to the ground.
10 June 1973, 2-1 vs. USSR, Central V.I. Lenin Stadium, Moskva
Vladimir Muntian scored a 66th minute penalty kick against Peter Shilton.

1973-74
22 May 1974, 2-2 vs. Argentina, Empire Stadium, Wembley
Mario Kempes scored an 89th minute penalty kick against Peter Shilton.

1974-75
24 May 1975, 5-1 vs. Scotland, Wembley Stadium, Wembley
Bruce Rioch scored Scotland's only goal with a 41st minute penalty kick against Ray Clemence.

1976-77
8 September 1976, 1-1 vs. Republic of Ireland, Wembley Stadium, Wembley
Gerry Daly scored a 52nd minute penalty kick against Ray Clemence.
31 May 1977, 0-1 vs. Wales, Wembley Stadium, Wembley
Leighton James scored a 44th minute penalty kick against Peter Shilton.

1978-79
20 September 1978, 4-3 vs. Denmark, Idrætsparken, København
Allan Simonsen scored a 25th minute penalty kick against Ray Clemence.

1979-80
17 October 1979, 5-1 vs. Northern Ireland, Windsor Park, Belfast
Vic Moreland scored a 49th minute penalty kick against Peter Shilton after Mick Mills had brought down Sammy McIlroy.
13 May 1980, 3-1 vs. Argentina, Wembley Stadium, Wembley
Following Kenny Sansom's sliding tackle on Diego Maradona, Daniel Passarella scored a 54th minute penalty kick against Ray Clemence.
31 May 1980, 3-1 vs. Argentina, Sydney Cricket Ground, Sydney
Gary Cole scored a 88th minute penalty kick against Joe Corrigan.

1980 European Championship Finals
18 June 1980, 2-1 vs. Spain, Stadio San Paolo, Napoli
Dani's first penalty kick after 48 minutes against Ray Clemence.

1980-81
15 October 1980, 1-2 vs. Romania, Stadionul 23 August, Bucureşti
Anghel Iordănescu scored an 75th minute penalty kick against Ray Clemence.
23 May 1981, 0-1 vs. Scotland, Wembley Stadium, Wembley
John Robertson scored a 64th minute penalty kick against Joe Corrigan.

1981-82
3 June 1982, 4-1 vs. Finland, Olympiastadion, Helsinki
Kai Haaskivi scored an 83rd minute penalty kick against Ray Clemence.

1982-83
22 September 1982, 2-2 vs. Denmark, Idrætsparken, København
Allan Hansen scored a 69th minute penalty kick against Peter Shilton.

1983-84
21 September 1983, 0-1 vs. Denmark, Wembley Stadium, Wembley
Allan Simonsen became the first player to score two penalties when he scored a 38th minute penalty kick against Peter Shilton following a Phil Neal handball.
13 June 1984, 0-2 vs. Uruguay, Estadio Centenario, Montevideo
Luis Acosta scored an 8th minute penalty against Peter Shilton.

1984-85
6 June 1985, 1-2 vs. Italy, Estadio Azteca, ciudad de México
Alessandro Altobelli scored an 89th minute penalty against Peter Shilton.

1985-86
23 April 1986, 2-1 vs. Scotland, Wembley Stadium, Wembley
Graeme Souness scored a 57th minute penalty against Peter Shilton.

1988-89
8 February 1989, 2-1 vs. Greece, Olympiakó Stádio Spyros Louis, Athina
Dimitris Saravakos scored a first minute penalty against Peter Shilton.

1990 World Cup Finals
1 July 1990, 3-2 vs. Cameroon, Stadio San Paolo, Napoli
Emmanuel Kunde scored a 63rd minute penalty against Peter Shilton. Paul Gascoigne had brought down Roger Miller in the area.
7 July 1990, 1-2 vs. Italy, Stadio San Nicola, Bari
Salvatore Schillaci scored an 84th minute penalty against Peter Shilton.

1991-92
3 June 1992, 2-1 vs. Finland, Olympiastadion, Helsinki
Ari Hjelm scored a 27th minute penalty kick against Chris Woods.

1992-93
28 April 1993, 2-2 vs. Netherlands, Wembley Stadium, Wembley
Peter van Vossen 85th minute penalty kick sent Chris Woods the wrong way. Penalty was awarded after Des Walker began to hold back Marc Overmars' shirt outside the penalty area, collapsing inside the area.

1996 European Championship Finals
8 June 1996, 1-1 vs. Switzerland, Wembley Stadium, Wembley
Kubilay Türkyilmaz scored an 82nd minute penalty kick against David Seaman.

1997-98
11 February 1998, 0-2 vs. Chile, Wembley Stadium, London
Marcelo Salas scored a 79th minute penalty kick against Nigel Martyn.

1998 World Cup Finals
30 June 1998, 2-2 vs. Argentina, Stade Geoffroy-Guichard, Saint-Étienne
Gabriel Batistuta scored a 6th minute penalty kick against David Seaman.

2000 European Championship Finals
20 June 2000, 2-3 vs. Romania, Stade Communal, Charleroi
Ioan Ganea scored a 89th minute winning penalty kick against Nigel Martyn. Awarded after Phil Neville brought down Moldovan on the right.

2001-02
27 March 2002, 1-2 vs. Italy, Elland Road, Leeds
Vincenzo Montella scored a 92nd minute penalty kick against David James.

2002-03
22 May 2003, 2-1 vs. South Africa, ABSA Stadium, Durban
Benni McCarthy scored a 18th minute penalty kick against David James after Danny Mills handled the ball.

2003-04
16 November 2003, 2-3 vs. Denmark, Old Trafford, Manchester
Martin Jørgensen scored a 30th minute penalty kick against David James.

2004 European Championship Finals
13 June 2004, 1-2 vs. France, Estádio do SL Benfica, Lisboa
Zinedine Zidane scored a 93rd minute penalty kick against David James.

2007-08
17 October 2007, 1-2 vs. Russia, Olimpiyskiy Kompleks Luzhniki Stadion, Moskva
Roman Pavlyuchenko scored a 67th minute penalty kick against Paul Robinson. Wayne Rooney had clipped the feet of the sprinting Konstantin Zyryanov, initially, outside the penalty area, but as he was running into it.
26 March 2008, 0-1 vs. France, Stade de France, Saint-Denis
Franck Ribéry scored a 32nd minute penalty kick against David James. James had brought down the ensuing Nicola Anelka in the area.

2015-16
29 March 2016, 1-2 vs. Netherlands, The National Stadium, Wembley
Vincent Janssen scored a fiftieth minute penalty against Fraser Forster after Danny Rose handled the ball in the area.

2017-18
27 March 2018, 1-1 vs. Italy, The National Stadium, Wembley
Lorenzo Insigne scored a controversial 87th minute penalty against Jack Butland after debutant James Tarkowski stood on Chiesa's ankle. Awarded belatedly by VAR.