—"If any player shall intentionally trip put on hold an opposing player, or deliberately handle the ball within twelve yards from his own goal-line, the referee shall, on appeal, award the opposing side a penalty kick, to be taken from any point twelve yards from the goal-line, under the following conditions:-All players, with the exception of the player taking the penalty kick and the opposing goal-keeper (who shall not advance more than six yards from the goal-line) shall stand at least six yards behind the ball. The ball shall be in play when the kick is taken, and a goal may be scored from the penalty kick." - 2 June 1891, Glasgow

1891-92
5 March 1892, 2-0 vs. Ireland, Cliftonville Gardens, Belfast
 Towards the close of the match, a penalty kick was given against Underwood for fouling Torrans in the English goal mouth. Sam Torrans' kick proved abortive as Bill Rowley saved it and nothing further resulted.

"but the ball shall not be again played by the kicker until it has been played by another player. If necessary, time of play shall be extended to admit of the penalty kick being taken." - 13 June 1892, Llandudno

1896-97
20 February 1897, 6-0 vs. Ireland, Trentbridge Cricket Ground, Nottingham
Bob Milne, between the 75th and 85th minutes, missed his penalty kick against the debuting Jack Robinson, after Bill Williams had fouled John Darling in the area. Milne's kick went wide.

—"A suitable mark shall be made opposite each goal-post, 18 yards from the goal-line, to assist the Referee in enforcing the regulations as regards the penalty kick under Law 14.". - 17 June 1901, Giant's Causeway

1901-02
22 March 1902, 1-0 vs. Ireland, Balmoral Showgrounds,  Belfast
Bob Milne's second half penalty kick is saved against Bill George. The kick was awarded after Bob Crompton had fisted away the ball within the twelve-yard line.

—"In the event of any intentional infringement of Law 10 by the defending side within the penalty area, the Referee shall award the opponents a penalty kick which shall be taken from the penalty kick mark under the following conditions ;—All players, with the exception of the player taking the penalty kick and the opponents' goal-keeper shall be outside the penalty area. The opponents' goal-keeper shall be within the goal area. The ball must be kicked forward. The ball shall be in play when the kick is taken, and a goal may be scored from a penalty kick ; but the ball shall not be again played by the kicker until it has been played by another player. If necessary, time of play shall be extended to admit of the penalty kick being taken. A free kick shall also be awarded to the opposite side if the ball is not kicked forward, or is played a second time by the player who takes the penalty kick, until it has been played by another player." - 16 June 1902, Scarborough

1902-03
4 April 1903, 1-2 vs. Scotland, Bramall Lane, Sheffield
Only The Observer reports that Finlay Speedie's penalty kick is saved by Tom Baddeley.

1907-08
16 March 1908, 7-1 vs. Wales, The Racecourse, Wrexham
Billy Meredith missed his 43rd minute penalty kick against Horace Bailey. Bob Crompton had fouled Tinker Davies, but Meredith shot wide. England were leading a nine-man Welsh team 4-0.

1908-09
13 April 1909, 2-0 vs. Scotland, Sports Arena, Penge
Jimmy Stark low and hard penalty kick was hit straight at Sam Hardy. The penalty was given by his namesake, James Stark, after he harshly adjudged that Jesse Pennington handled the ball, he had apparently fisted the ball over his own line.

1930-31
22 November 1930, 4-0 vs. Wales, Racecourse Ground, Wrexham
Fred Keenor's 71st minute penalty kick is shot straight at Harry Hibbs.

1934-35
29 September 1934, 4-0 vs. Wales, Ninian Park, Cardiff
Billy Evans penalty kick went wide of the goal against Harry Hibbs.
6 February 1935, 2-1 vs. Ireland, Goodison Park, Liverpool
Jackie Coulter's 57th minute penalty kick hit the Harry Hibbs' crossbar, after Eddie Hapgood had handled the ball. If Coulter had scored, it would have put Ireland 2-1 up. There was a great hesitancy in taking the kick, as no Irish player wanted to step up and take responsibility.

1959-60
18 November 1959, 2-1 vs. Northern Ireland, Empire Stadium, Wembley
Jimmy McIlroy penalty kick is saved against the debuting Ron Springett.

1961-62
20 May 1962, 4-0 vs. Peru, Estadio Nacional Coloso de José Díaz, Lima
Oscar Montalvo penalty kick is saved against Ron Springett.

1968-69
12 June 1969, 1-2 vs. Brazil, Estádio Jornalista Mário Filho, Rio de Janeiro
Carlos Alberto's 28th minute penalty kick is saved against Gordon Banks.

1980 European Championship Finals
18 June 1980, 2-1 vs. Spain, Stadio San Paolo, Napoli
Dani's first penalty kick was successfully converted, but the retake was saved by Ray Clemence.

1984-85
12 June 1985, 3-0 vs. West Germany, Estadio Azteca, ciudad de México
Andreas Brehme's penalty kick was saved by Peter Shilton.

1985-86
26 March 1986, 1-0 vs. USSR, Dinamo Stadion, Tbilisi
Aleksandr Chivadze's 15th minute penalty kick hit the post of the goal guarded by Peter Shilton.

1996 European Championship Finals
15 June 1996, 2-0 vs. Scotland, Wembley Stadium, Wembley
Gary McAllister's penalty kick was saved by David Seaman's left elbow.

1996-97
1 September 1996, 3-0 vs. Moldova, Stadionul Republican, Chişinău
Ion Testimitanu had his penalty kick hit the against David Seaman's crossbar.

1998-99
14 October 1998, 3-0 vs. Luxembourg, Stade Josy Barthel, Stad Lëtzebuerg
Dany Theis' 5th minute penalty kick was hit wide past David Seaman.

1999-2000
3 June 2000, 2-1 vs. Malta, The National stadium, Ta'Qali
David Carabott's 28th minute penalty kick hit the post, it did, however, end in the net after it rebounded in of debutant Richard Wright. Recorded as a Wright own goal.
David Carabott's 88th minute penalty kick is saved by the feet of Wright, after he gave away the second penalty of the match.

2000-01
28 February 2001, 3-0 vs. Spain, Villa Park, Birmingham
Javi Moreno 78th minute penalty kick was saved by Nigel Martyn.
25 March 2001, 4-0 vs. Mexico, Pride Park, Derby
José Abundis 65th minute penalty kick was missed when it went wide past David James.

2004-05
17 November 2004, 0-1 vs. Spain, Estadio Santiago Bernabéu, Madrid
Raúl's 25th minute penalty kick was saved by Paul Robinson.

2009-10
10 October 2009, 0-1 vs. Ukraine, Stadion Dnepr-Arena, Dnepropetrovsk
Andriy Shevchenko's 16th minute penalty kick hit the outside of the post and went wide, against David James.
14 November 2009, 0-1 vs. Brazil, Khalifa International Stadium, ad-Dawḥa, Qatar
Luís Fabiano's 56th minute penalty kick was hit over the crossbar against Ben Foster.

2012-13
6 February 2013, 2-1 vs. Brazil, The National Stadium, Wembley
Ronaldinho's 19th minute penalty was saved twice by Joe Hart.